top of page

The Suspicious Case of the Pyjama Bottoms: AI-Inspired Short Story

Introduction : This episodic short story (only in summary form at the moment) was inspired by a prompt for a fiction book idea I entered into ChatGPT – “Write a fiction book about a lady with a strong Northern English accent finding the nemesis of the story's pajama bottoms and telling a friend, in these words: 'And it smelled musty'.”; I’m not entirely certain whether I am reaching the right target audience with the concept generally (or whether I have enough of a following to attract views etc.), and also, for a heads-up, I wrote this when I was very tired haha, but here it is anyway…it’s the whole script rewritten in my own words straightforwardly, really, and this is what I like to do in spare time/a hobby. I’ve also kept the chapter titles the same as the ChatGPT initial prompt response.

​

Chapter 1: A Bit of Bother at the Historical Society
The Grimley Historical Society stood grand and decadent amid the forest, a monument to elegance and dignity. But not as of last night. See, last night this building was burglarized. 
Yet, not successfully, surprisingly. Yes, an ancient ledger was suddenly missing from the archives, and yes, a pair of pyjama bottoms were left behind, but – wait, what was that?? A pair of pyjama bottoms?!
Seriously, as if this night could get any stranger…
Chapter 2: Mags and Her KitKat
Not quite so nearby lived a quick-witted widow with a keen sense of justice by the name of Mags Higginbottom. Having been made aware of the news over the course of the night by some close associates, she set out to find the perpetrator. 
With her, she brings a Kit-Kat bar, her friend Carla, and a torch that stretches out into the blue sky beyond. 
Chapter 3: The Musty Discovery
Mags arrives at a nearby house – resident: a good old geezer named Neville Pargetter. Upon entering his bedroom, she finds a pair of pyjama bottoms lying crossed over his bed. 
She sniffs at them gingerly with her hairy nose, recoiling in fits of disgust. Turning around to Carla (who had stayed outside while this was happening), she utters this simple statement in a low tone with a curious inflection: “And it smelled musty”.
Chapter 4: Meet the Suspects
Neville, having returned from the kitchen in a failed attempt to boil his evening egg, urges for Mags and Carla to consider him as innocent. They are, both, not convinced.
Mags and Carla each take to the kitchen table and furiously discuss and begin to list of the possible suspects: ex-actress Dottie, shifty Father Colin, and Barry from the butcher’s further along in town.
Chapter 5: Women's Institute Espionage
Mags, having weighed all of her options and used every personal resource available, approaches the Women’s Institute and persuades the organisation to “volunteer” to help “get the town back in ship-shape”.
The whole time, however, she utilises the group’s distracted attention to spy on suspects’ homes and their daily schedules.
Chapter 6: The Lavender Scent
Whilst investigating Dottie’s house, Mags finds some different pyjama pants – these ones smell of lavender. Joining the dots, she sees this as constructive evidence that Neville from down the road was framed.
Chapter 7: The Village Whispers
However, word of Mags’ investigations creeps into town and spreads through the village. Mags hears muffled conversations with her recon activity as the topic but finds that she can’t make sense of any of it. She and Carla get to connecting odd behaviours noticed around the town from earlier. 
Chapter 8: A Secret at the Vicarage
Spying on Father Colin, Mags finds him acting inordinarily; following this, she sees him, in the plain light of day, concealing some old sheets of paper beneath the wheelbarrow in his garden. She finds assorted documents on further inspection – the most noteworthy being a Victorian birth certificate for a female – Elsie Margaret Pargetter.
Chapter 9: A Heir Uncovered
Mags channels her inner detective, assuming and estimating that the papers hold the secrets revolving around unclaimed inheritance rights, and that the birth certificate could trace back to a long forgotten – yet rightful – heir. 
Chapter 10: Neville’s Shame
Neville concedes to Mags that he’d heard of the birth certificate (and the heir) but had wanted to bury it all. Becoming visibly flustered, he decides to defend himself – no, he did not take the ledger because he was too scared to.
Chapter 11: Dottie’s Denial
Dottie’s worries come to the fore; she knew about the heir to the inheritance, as she tells Mags – it was her granddaughter. She, also, doesn’t own up to stealing it but becomes agitated when questioned; perhaps about something else?
Chapter 12: Vicar Under Surveillance
Mags and Carla find out more about Father Colin – he has been hiding other documents. Mags grabs them all for herself and declares: “And it smelled musty”.
Chapter 13: Barry and the Ledger Trail
Barry, the butcher of the village, discloses some specific facts about himself that make Mags and Carla and most of the villagers conclude that he is a closet historian. There was a strong possibility that he was going to uncover the truth behind the corruption inherent within the village but couldn’t stay away from doing some recon instead.
Chapter 14: The Hidden Passage
Underground, below the Historical Society building, a tunnel is found which leads to a chamber full of secret treasures. Mags, again tuning into her detective mode, draws out evidence revealing that the chamber wasn’t underused – someone had been there recently. 
Chapter 15: Danger in the Darkness
Mags and Carla delve deeper through the chamber, nearly stepping on a bear-trap (quite apparently that was designed to deter prying eyes). In their discovery, they find another, more dated document.
Chapter 16: The Ruse Revealed
The women come to an agreement that two separate documents exist – one is real and might hold the key to inheritance, and the other is forged. Someone is trying to send them down the wrong line of investigation.
Chapter 17: Dottie's True Role
Down to her last reserves, Dottie claims it was, in fact, her: she had placed the pyjama bottoms in Neville’s house in order to frame him; she took the birth certificate from its rightful owner in order to protect her granddaughter.
Chapter 18: Tea and Truth
Mags, intending to make amends, returns the birth certificate. The village’s council is stunned. Mags and Carla become the unofficial investigators of the village of Grimley.
Chapter 19: Cleaning Up Neville
Meanwhile, after becoming too embarrassed and frustrated with the whole affair, Neville walks down the village road to sell his house and moves abroad. Father Colin stands down from his duties of faith for a “spiritual break”.
Chapter 20: Epilogue – Victoria Sponges and Vindication
Mags and Carla return to their shared apartment, having a great deal of tea (and fun) recounting the tale of their victory, with their heartfelt discussion finishing with Mags once more administering the line: “And it smelled musty”.
 

© Michael Soar, 2025.

 Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page